Holding steady in the liminal years

 

Peach preserves waiting to be decanted, smallish terracotta pots on the verandah lined up waiting for planting, another chapter with footnotes to be rechecked, giant dog unable to understand the words ‘Sit’ or ‘Stay’.  I look at the syrup-glazed peaches and think of  eating my own bottled peaches  with thick custard on a cold winter evening, look at the pots  standing in a row and think of tumbling  fuschias in scarlet and purple, the  lively mauve of the ribbon bush, sprawling apple-mint and lemon-scented pelargoniums. One of these days the chapter will be checked and tidied up and ready for publication, the agony over. One of these days the  adorable lunatic puppy will be a well-behaved obedient dog.

An American visitor from Atlanta, Georgia, dressed vividly in  a red and blue tropicana T-shirt, a black sun visor, strings of  local ochre clay beads dangling from her neck and wrists,  stops by to ask me for some parsley. In one hasty gulp of breath she tells me she voted for Obama, she does not support American aggression abroad, she  likes to think of herself as different from other American tourists, she is genuinely interested in  the problems of rural Africa, she tries to contribute meaningfully, tries to show respect for cultural difference, feels she can learn from the heroic liberation efforts and  staggering natural  beauty etc of the Third World.  Fortunately she runs out of breath and I  assure her we don’t see  all Americans as Ugly Americans,  give her  a large bunch of flourishing Italian parsley.  She thanks me as if I have given her a gilt-edged credit card or a wide-eyed baby to adopt. Guilt and privilege seems an inescapable combination. And tourism worldwide lends itself to satire, exposing the increasingly homogenous ‘global culture’ where, in the search for different cultures, those exotic fascinating different cultures are destroyed. My parsley-clutching acquaintance says  how she loves to meet  black  South Africans and listen to them talk about their  dreams and  hardships.

Well, I could give her a list of black South African entrepreneurs living in Atlanta, Georgia, and  more than willing to talk to her about their dreams and hardships, but  that wouldn’t be the same thing, would it? The writer Geoff Dyer wrote a piece on the charm of American travellers in which he comments:

The archetypal American abroad is perceived as loud and crass even though actually existing American tourists are distinguished by the way they address bus drivers and bartenders as “sir” and are effusive in their thanks when any small service is rendered. We look on with some confusion at these encounters because, on the one hand, the Americans seem a bit country-bumpkinish, and, on the other, good manners are a form of sophistication.

The tranquillity and  delightful unsociableness of our post-Christmas respite is over. There is  a luncheon party on a nearby farm, the  80th birthday of the former art teacher,  friends arriving for  New Year’s Eve, more friends arriving on New Year’s Day.  More Asian chicken salad, more homebaked bread,  a watermelon, feta and black olives salad, another baked ham, a berry pavlova perhaps, jugs of  lemonade with  fresh mint leaves. The skies are cloudless, the nights starry and brilliant, warm and scented. If the guests don’t get heat stroke, it will be perfect.

Whatever it was — that unsteadying combination of unhappy or traumatic factors — that flipped me so off-balance in December has gone. As if we had jumped over a hurdle and now just have to turn the corner into another year. At night, I light candles on the verandah and sit there watching the moon come up over the  mountains, just breathing in the silence and the  spaciousness within.

We live in fragile and liminal times of collapsing economies,  global conflict, shifting and threatened climates and ecologies, older nationalisms falling away along with so many older certainties — we need different and more responsive traditions, more frugality, more authentic ways of connecting from different places. Goodwill is not enough. How to become more flexible, receptive, less fearful, rigid, judgmental? I have no idea really  and watch the  moon whiten the fields,  the stars of the Southern Cross filling the skies with brightness.

About these ads

18 comments to Holding steady in the liminal years

  1. I wish Americans would not go to other lands and apologetically speak of their own as if it were somehow inferior. But what do I know?

    • louisey says:

      I don’t think inferiority is the issue for most American tourists — they see the impact US multinationals, oil companies and military have had across Africa and want to stand apart from that. And it is hard to be identified with a world power so detested in many places when you love your country and want it and yourself to be seen differently.

  2. I love this post! The last sentence, especially…

  3. Susan M says:

    I’d like to thank you for this lovely post, but I’d hate to sound boorish and effusive. I love to travel. What others think of me, both here and abroad, luckily, is none of my business.

    • louisey says:

      Hi Susan — we all live with stereotypes of tourists and how they interact with locals and whether their foreign currency is harmful or helpful. I think they days of international tourism are coming to an end as the economy crashes and the stereotypes will fall away in time.

  4. Ellen says:

    Interesting about the tourist…’Guilt and privilege seem an inescapable combination’ seems true, especially in our time. It didn’t used to be so I think. Could be a step up from complete obliviousness.

    Good to hear your Christmas gloom has now dissipated. Mine hasn’t yet, but it will.

    • louisey says:

      Ellen I think it is a step up from obliviousness, to realise handing out dollars doesn’t alter perceptions of tourists as exploitative or insensitive.

      Hope you have a good New Year’s Eve.

  5. Syd says:

    I want to be a traveler and not a tourist. I think there is a difference and one of the reasons that I would not want to be part of a tourist group. I like the Motorcycle Diaries and how Che traveled. That would be the way to see a country if one could live through the adventure.

  6. Pam says:

    I believe that in Texas, good manners are the common denominator between the wealthiest and poorest residents. It is more like pride, than anything else.
    There is a small island in Mexico called Cozumel and it is one of my favorite places to visit. Unfortunately, the cruise lines dock their and let everyone loose in the very small town. It drives me crazy when all the young women come on land with a bathing suit top on and short shorts. The towns women in Cozumel are modest and the island is their home. I don’t like that the tourists think that any old way to dress is appropriate because they are on vacation.

    • louisey says:

      Pam I have just been reading about Cozumel — the truth is all of us want to be ideal travellers and to be welcome wherever we go. But out here for example, foreign exchange differences mean that 100 American dollars is worth more than most people would earn in four or five years and that disparity alone means you can buy up anything you want without having to pay for it as you would back home. That alone ensures exploitation, a cheap as dirt holiday and the local left with nothing to show except for the intrusion of busloads of noisy people trashing resorts and wanting MacDonalds in the middle of the jungle etc. And then we have sex tourism, South Africa’s biggest holiday industry, sigh.

  7. Jan BB says:

    No matter where I live in the world, once I open my mouth, into the the American box I go. It takes willingness for someone to actually see and hear me, Jan – the person and not the preconceived cultural mindset.

    • louisey says:

      Perceptions, yes, we’ve talked about this before — and I found when I was in the UK people automatically thought my accent was South African although it is Zimbabwean. It takes time as well as willingness, I think — and many out here have had horrible experiences which is why the Ugly American abroad is so detested.

  8. akannie says:

    Liminal times indeed…I am waiting and watching. How exciting and terrifying to live in these times.

    I have been outside this country a few times and even within these borders I feel like an outsider from time to time. In Atlanta, Georgia, for instance. lol And it’s one of the most metropolitan southern towns you’ll find.

    I think it all comes back to the age old tenets of knowing your own history and finding the place where your own roots can sink deep…and learning to live simply and sustainably. The world is very disconnected for the most part from the realities of the simplest things.

    I am going to open a can of peaches and eat them, I think. From my tree that I planted and harvested.

  9. Lou says:

    Don’t get me started on bad behavior. I grew up in Europe, mostly on military bases, where every week end young American soldiers would get drunk and go into town, making fools of themselves. Most people wrote it off as youth and loneliness, but since I was both German and American I was often embarrassed. Especially when Americans made fun of the people or culture in loud voices, thinking no one understood English. Almost everyone in Europe speaks English, it’s Americans that don’t want to learn the native language. I know this is not true of all tourists, but I totally get what you are saying in that we try to overcompensate for our wealth. When I was in northern China, women laid deformed infants on the cold sidewalk, leaving them alone there for the day, with a cup for donations. The mothers would have to go back to the fields to work. What difference was I going to make in their lives by putting a $1 or $5 in the cup as I took pictures with my $600 nikon.

    • louisey says:

      You get me, Lou, you really do.

      In the early ’90s I watched the American fleet in the Persian Gulf put into Mombasa in East Africa for ‘rest and recreation.’ They vandalised the port, desecrated mosques and looted shops, offended the locals, had numerous charges of rape laid against them. The military police with the US forces just went around bribing complainants with dollars and threats. The issue isn’t that there are kind and sensitive Americans out there, it has to do with wealth and power. What Americans may give to Africa in terms of funding is zilch in comparison with what they take away in terms of oil and exploited resources. The world should not be an oil reserve or playground for rich Americans. And when people from the First World talk about being ‘travellers’ rather than ‘tourists’ I applaud but tell them to learn Swahili or isiXhosa before they visit so they can really talk to the locals. Learning a foreign language is not easy but millions in the Third World learn seven or eight languages in order to get jobs or relocate. Other nations have stereotypes too — Germans, Swiss, the English — but no other nation has the same clout or does as much harm. That’s how the world is right now in terms of a power struggle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s